Showing posts with label Secularism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Secularism. Show all posts

Sunday, December 10, 2017

Is Rahul Gandhi a Hindu? And is this important?

There is currently a debate going on India about whether Rahul Gandhi, the scion of the Nehru-Gandhi dynasty and the soon-to-be President of the Congress Party, is a Hindu or not. The debate started during the campaign for the Gujarat state elections. It was reported that Rahul signed the register for non-Hindus while visiting the Somnath Temple. The BJP is now accusing Rahul of not being a Hindu and falsely posing as a Hindu while the Congress is trying to prove that Rahul is a Hindu. 

Robin David, the resident editor of The Times of India's Chandigarh edition, has written an enlightening article on what this debate about Rahul's Hinduness means for Indians who are not Hindus.


The loud and coarse debate over which register Rahul Gandhi signed when he visited Somnath temple has led to politicians of both Congress and BJP using an awkward hyphenation – the ‘non-Hindu’. With campaigning peaking in Gujarat, no one has bothered about how this ‘Hindu vs non-Hindu’ debate has marginalised those who are not Hindus. It has erased the many unique distinctions among different groups and reduced them to one broad, generalised category – the non-Hindu.
You are not a Christian or a Parsi or a Muslim or a Jew. You are a non-Hindu. Sit on the sidelines and watch us fight over who the real Hindu is, is the message BJP and Congress have driven home.
Given the manner in which both parties are fighting over the issue, it seems that the ‘Hindu’ is an exclusive club for the privileged. To become a member, you have to meet the stiff criteria set by the club management and be ready for a rejection.
By questioning Rahul’s Hindu identity, the BJP has challenged his membership to the club and asked him to establish his credentials. Although BJP leaders haven’t said it in as many words, the implicit message is that Rahul does not deserve to ask for the votes of Hindus in Gujarat because his Hindu credentials are questionable. BJP spokesperson Sambit Patra even demanded that Rahul “must say who he actually is”.
Rahul Gandhi in the Somnath Temple


The Indian Express has noted the same phenomenon but has ignored its implications for the minorities and the future of secularism in India. In their article, Gujarat assembly elections 2017: Rahul Gandhi’s devotion to temple politics catches BJP off guard, they point out that Rahul has visited 25 temples so far and it is the first time that party leadership of both major parties is trying to outdo each other in visiting temples. A excerpt from the article is reproduced below:

There is a new facet emerging in the Gujarat Assembly elections, the first phase of voting for which ended on Friday. Never before have temples played such a major role in politics of the state, since it was formed in 1960. The individual Hindu candidates used to launch their campaigning and election exercises by paying obeisance at their local temples or to their family deities, but the party top brass leading the campaign have never bothered to visit practically all important temples in their areas or on the route of their campaign.
This time, both the major political parties — the Congress and the BJP — have made it a point that their star campaigners visit important local temples wherever they go to address public meetings. While it was quite obvious for Prime Minister Narendra Modi or BJP national president Amit Shah to do so because of their religious background and RSS connections, it is quite new for Congress vice-president Rahul Gandhi to visit temples.
If it is a matter of prestige for the BJP and particularly, Modi, to ensure that his party retains the political power in the state as this election is being viewed as a precursor to the outcome in 2019 Lok Sabha elections, the Congress is doing everything available at its disposal to ensure that it wrests Gujarat from BJP after 22 years, to improve its prospects in 2019 general elections and come back to power at the Centre.

Sunday, September 17, 2017

Nepal: Rare example of decline in religious nationalism

The blog post is based on the masters' thesis of David Rangdrol, Uppsala University (Sweden). The thesis was written in 2007 and is titled, "Religious Nationalism in Nepal: Understanding the Demise of the Hindu Kingdom." Most of my blog posts are about countries where religious nationalism is increasing but this one will be focusing on a country where religious nationalism declined, something rare as Mr. Rangdrol explains: 

Until 2006 Nepal was known as “the only Hindu Kingdom in the world.” The Hindu attribute has its roots in the creation of Nepal in the 18th century; it was written down in the highest law of the land in 1854 and finally enshrined in the constitution from 1962 onwards. But 2006 marked a year of important transitions for Nepal: from civil war to peace, from totalitarianism to democracy, and from religious nationalism to secularism. This last point is particularly interesting given the larger context. The above-mentioned study [of 120 armed conflicts that occurred in Asia between 1946 and 2005] has found that a majority of conflicts (21 out of 31) that had a religious incompatibility at their core involved rebel groups that fought governments against secularism in order to establish religious states. Nepal on the other hand is the unique case in Asia in the past 60 years where a rebel group, the Maoists, has fought a government and included a demand for secularism in its agenda. Though the Maoist People’s War cannot be characterised primarily as an anti-religious war, the demand for a secular state was an important part of it. In any case, the most outstanding event that we will try to explain in this essay is that Nepal has officially shifted from religious nationalism to secularism in May 2006, effectively erasing an important, centennial feature of Nepal – to the dismay of Hindu nationalists.(p-7 of  Mr. Rangrol's unpublished thesis)

The literature used to help answer the research question is: Mark Juergensmeyer, The New Cold War: Religious Nationalism Confronts the Secular State; Nikki R. Keddie, The New Religious Politics: Where, When, and Why Do “Fundamentalisms” Appear?; and Gabriel A. Almond, R. Scott Appleby, Emmanuel Sivan, Strong Religion: The Rise of Fundamentalisms Around the World.

According to Mr. Rangdrol, following were the four main reasons for the decline of religious nationalism in Nepal:

1. There was no failed post-colonial secular nation-building experience:. Most the nations where religious nationalism has arisen in the last three decades were witness to a high expectations period after independence from European powers when a primarily secular leadership took over and led the country. However, this leadership failed to deliver and there was marked disappointment. The ensuing soul-searching by the people (and efforts of the religious elite) made religious nationalism popular. Nepal was never colonized so there was no secular legacy. Nepal was united by Gorkha King Prithvi Narayan Shah in 1769 as a Hindu Kingdom and remained so till 2006. Rangdrol describes how Hinduism was linked to the Nepali Kingdom from the start and how Nepali Kings and Ranas promoted Hinduism and proclaimed Nepal as the real and the only Hindu Kingdom in the world as India, despite being bigger, was ruled by initially by the Mughals and then by the British:

In 1769, Prithivi Narayan Shah, brought small independent states, chiefdoms and principalities of different ethnicities and religions under his control and created modern Nepal. The first Gorkha King declared Nepal asali Hindustan, the “true land of Hindus,” and “garden of four varnas and thirty-six jats.” The kings became widely revered as an incarnation of god Vishnu, one of the main gods of the modern Hindu pantheon. Though scholars disagree on the intensity with which Hinduisation and cultural assimilation was thereafter implemented, it remains clear that Nepal espoused the identity of a Hindu state from its very inception, and that over time non-Hindu indigenous, nature-worshipping, animist or Buddhist people have been gradually ‘Hinduized’ as a result of the conquest of the Hindu Kings and the migration of Parbatiyas (high-caste hill people) to different parts of Nepal.” In 1846, members of a powerful family, the Ranas, relegated the Gorkha monarchy to a secondary role and effectively became the rulers of Nepal, establishing a legacy of dictatorial prime ministers that lasted over a century.
The Ranas chose to build on the Hindu foundations that the Gorkha Kings had laid before them: In 1854, Jangabahadur, the first Rana minister, introduced laws based on Hinduism and divided the country hierarchically, subordinating all other nationalities to the Brahmins and Kshetris (Khas) ruling class. The civil code of 1854 the Muluki Ain (law of the land) cemented the cast system and ensured that the rulers would exercise total control over a static society: “Grounded in the Hindu idea of ritual purity, the Muluki Ain regulated the lives of every citizen from birth to death, making social or political mobility almost impossible.” From then, the process of Hinduisation under the Ranas though not overtly aggressive but rather “gradual and almost imperceptible” had its effects, of which the slow, piecemeal adoption of Hindu traditions and the dominance of the Higher castes. One political function of this was to project a distinct image of Nepal vis-à-vis India which was seen as “defiled” by Mughal Muslim rule and called pejoratively “Muglan” (land of Mughals). Jang Bahadur Rana thus spoke: “We have our own country, a Hindu rajya [state], where laws prescribe the cows shall not be slaughtered; nor women and Brahmins sentenced to capital punishment…In this age of Kali this is the only where Hindus rule.” The Rana rule came to an abrupt end in the 1950s. This tumultuous decade also saw Nepal’s first democratic experiment, which lasted until 1960 when the Gorkha dynasty staged a royal coup and took back the power it has lost to the Ranas a century before. (p-24-25)

Source: Nationalism vs. Patriotism: What will save Nepal?

In 1962, King Mahendra came up with a new constitution under which the king not only reigned but also ruled on top of a panchayat regime. The new constitution enshrined rights of all Nepalis but the position of Hinduism was also secured. Nepal was declared a Hindu kingdom and cow, the national animal, and promoting conversion of religion was prohibited. The king was the source of all power and he had to be a Hindu of Aryan descent:

Article 20: His Majesty-the Source of Power
(1) In this Constitution the words ‘His Majesty’ mean His Majesty the King for the time being reigning, being a descendant of King Prithivi Narayan Shah and adherent of Aryan culture and Hindu religion.
(2) The sovereignty of Nepal is vested in His Majesty and all powers-executive, legislative and judicial emanate from Him. These powers are exercised by His Majesty through the organs established by or under this Constitution and other laws for the time being in force keeping in view the interest and wishes of His Majesty’s subjects according to the highest traditions of the Shah dynasty. (1962 Constitution)
Furthermore, the Panchayat regime safeguarded the continuance of traditional Hindu customs and religion at the lower level.

This system continued till 1990 when large-scale demonstrations forced the king to give up power. In the aftermath, for the first time in Nepal, secularism was discussed as an alternative to religious nationalism. The 1990 constitution replaced the party-less Panchayat system with a democratic multi-party system. There were more rights for minorities and the hold of monarchy and culture and tradition (of which Hinduism was a big part) was reduced. However, Nepal was still a Hindu kingdom and cow the national animal (1990 Constitution).

The 1990 Constitution continued till 2006. The period under the 1990 Constitution was tumultuous. Nepali Maoists started a civil war in 1996 and a royal massacre happened in which Crown Prince Dipendra killed nine members of the royal family (including King and Queen) before killing himself. The new King Gyanendra also showed his assertiveness by dismissing several governments and, in the end, imposing a state of emergency to directly rule Nepal.

It is obvious from the above discussion that Nepal was never secular. It remained a united Hindu kingdom from 1769 till 2006, ruled by a Hindu god-king, who claimed to be an incarnation of one of the principal deities of Hinduism, Vishnu. 

2. Nepal was a fragile and poor country: Literature on religious nationalism indicates that a weak state may lead people and elites to look for answers to what went wrong. As mentioned above, it was the failure of the secular experiment (in terms of economic, social and political development) that has resulted in the rise of religious nationalism in many countries. Nepal had the opposite experience of these countries. It did not experience the failure of the secular experiment; it experienced the disastrous consequences of a religious experiment. As Rangdrol explains, Nepal, social and economic indicators were one of the worse in the world:

Things were not well in the Hindu Kingdom. Nepal has a history of totalitarianism, punctuated by coups, popular revolutions, and democratic experiments that only highlighted the governing elite’s political immaturity and proclivity for corruption. As the authors of People Politics and Ideology: Democracy and Social Change in Nepal explain, legitimacy rests to a great extent on economic development.125 Nepal is one of the poorest nations in Asia. Four out of ten people live with less than one Dollar a day. Nepal ranks 138 and 147 out of 177 in the Human Development and Gross Domestic Product indexes.126 The infrastructure, especially in the capital, cannot support its growing population. Traffic is abysmal and dangerous; sewage overflows daily and spreads deadly disease in the monsoon rain, and the air quality ranks Kathmandu the second most polluted city in Asia.(p-38)
Therefore, people rejected the religious nationalism and opted for something new and different i.e. secular nationalism. 

3. No internal or external enemy that belonged to another religion: Threat from religious groups, different from one's own, is one of the primary reasons for the rise in religious nationalism in many countries. When a group identifies its enemy group on the basis of their religion, religion becomes not only a marker but also the primary reason for the conflict. The enemy group can be internal or external i.e. within the borders or outside it. According to the 2001 Census, Hindus constitute more than 80% of the Nepali population. The biggest religious minority are Buddhists, who are around 8% of the population, and most Hindus consider them a part of Hinduism, not a minority. Muslims and Christians, around 4% and 0.5% respectively, are the only "real" minorities but there was no history of tension between Hindus and Muslims and Christian as described by Rangdol:

Religious nationalist movements are typically exploiting threats of an “other,” which helps them mobilise people to their cause. But that “other” is difficult to locate in Nepal. Nepal was never a colony, neither Christians nor Muslims invaded it, it has experienced no large-scale inter-religious violence nor any other type of traumatic event that can be credibly blamed on this or that religious minority...it is clear that religious demographics show a solid Hindu majority with Buddhists for main minority. It is not customary to talk about Hindu-Buddhist confrontations, and it is very difficult for most Hindus to demonise or speak of a ‘Buddhist threat’ for the simple reason that they take Buddhism as a branch of Hinduism. (p-42)
Maoists, although instrumental in the fall of religious nationalism in Nepal, were also not considered enemy:
If not the secular west, the local secular elite, or religious minorities, who else then could personify an anti-Hindu enemy? The Maoists perhaps? After all, it is them who have asked for a secular state at the point of AK-47s, and they are communists and therefore should be in principle atheists? Although many religious nationalists perceive Maoists as enemies144 – being the brute force behind the fall of the Hindu Kingdom – they have not been widely portrayed directly in terms of an “anti-religious” force.145 In general, Maoists do not fit the anti-religious/atheist communist stereotype. The Maoists seem to have managed a skilled balancing act: on the one hand harvesting the grievances left by decades of pro-Hindu discrimination, and, on the other, being careful enough not to harm Hindu or traditional sentiments. Though the CPN-M official banners display the usual communist avatars146 alongside their leader Prachanda, they have differed from Mao and some of his acolytes in that they have not proactively promoted atheism and anti-religious policies. Although it is reported that there were incidents in the People’s War, especially at the beginning, that involved iconoclastic gestures such as destroying temples or intimidating priests, they were quick to realise the strategic downside of those methods. They have managed to recruit all the marginalised people of the Hindu state system while they have also displayed respect for the Hindu religion and its traditions. (p-43)

Similarly, although Rangdol does not talk about it, there was no external enemy that belonged to another religion. Nepal has no external enemies but Nepalis often feel resentment towards India due to historic land and water disputes, the annexation of Sikkim, both actual and perceived slights by the big neighbor as well as direct intervention by India in Nepali affairs (See Bollywood Meets Nepali Nationalism). The religious "other," therefore, does not even exist outside Nepal, contributing to the decline of religious nationalism in Nepal.

4. Top-down religious nationalist structure: There were no religious nationalist political parties in Nepal during the from the 1950s to 2006. The major reason for this was the presence of Hindu king and declaration of Nepal as a Hindu kingdom. With a four-fifths majority in population and the most powerful man in Nepal on Hinduism side, there was apparently no need for a Hindu nationalist party. Compared to India, there was no history of religious mobilization in Nepal by Hindu nationalists. Therefore, when the king was ousted, religious nationalism went with him:

Part of the reason why there were no Hindu nationalist parties even in the 1990s rests on the historical structure of religious nationalism in Nepal: its top-bottom configuration. Hindu nationalism had been imposed from the top with authoritarian means from the very beginning. The institution of Kingship always secured the Hindu state, and therefore no bottom-up religiopolitical activism was ever needed to maintain religious nationalism...If one compares this trajectory to India the contrast is telling. In India, Hindu nationalism has a century of training by trial and error...In Nepal, with the King in a corner and intensified Maoist pressure, no strong alternative mediums were there to protect the interests of the Hindu state, and none of the political parties saw it as a vital part of their agenda. Hindu political parties did not emerge because there was no demand or need for them; state Hinduness was secure with the King. The 1990 secular debate was an alarming moment Hindu nationalists did not heed, there was no such instinct, no such culture. But not much could be expected in such a short lapse of time because social networks take time to form. (p-48)





Tuesday, July 28, 2015

Why a secular party is not allowed in Egypt?

Ahmed Fouad's article in Al-Monitor Is Egypt ready for a secular party? is about a recent attempt to form a secular party in Egypt. It is called Egyptian Secular Party (الحزب العلماني المصري). The article also traces three previous attempts to start such a party in Egypt. All of these attempts failed as Fouad explained:

  1. In 2004, Mohsen Lotfi al-Sayed and other intellectuals submitted incorporation request for a secular party Hizb-Masr al-Um (Mother Egypt Party). This request was rejected by the chamber of political parties’ affairs. After removing the reference to secularism from the incorporation charter and changing the name to Al Hizb al-Masri al-Liberali (Liberal Egyptian Party), another request was submitted but it was also rejected by the Mubarak administration.
  2. In 2011, novelist Alaa Hamed claimed that he wanted to start a secular party but was attacked by some Salafi leaders of Zifta city. Zifta residents denied his claim but no party was established. Fouad informs that Hamid was convicted of blasphemy in 1990 because of his book, The Void in a Man’s Mind: God’s Trial,
  3. In July 2013, after President Morsi's ouster in a coup, Shiite leader Bahaa Anwar called for the establishment of a secular Fajr Party and demanded disbanding of all religious parties. The name of the party was later changed to Secular Egypt Party but again no party was registered.

Egyptian Secular Party is formed by a group of people, most well-known of which is Hesham Ouf. Ouf is an Egyptian businessman and his previous political experience is limited to owning a marketing research firm that worked for Mohamed ElBaradei’s and Amr Moussa’s campaigns in the 2012 presidential elections. Egyptian Secular Party, according to New secular party to 'challenge religious dominance', wants to separate religion from politics, abolish religious education, and limit the power of Al-Azhar University that according to the party has become a state within a state.

Egyptian Secular Party formation has been widely criticized. Its leaders have been called crazy, atheists, extremists and collaborators and its agenda has been declared unconstitutional and against religious values of the Egyptian people. The charge of unconstitutionality is based on two grounds. First, secularism is a termed a religion (as Islam, Judaism etc.) and as Egyptian constitution bans all religion-based political parties, it is declared that a secular party is also unconstitutional. Second, secular party is deemed unconstitutional because it is against sharia, which is a part of the Egyptian constitution.

Fouad is not very enthusiastic about this latest attempt to establish secular party because of the lack of support from the Egyptian state:

The chances of establishing the party remain remote, especially in light of the lack of a clear position by the state. Establishing the party anytime soon could be difficult, given the question of its constitutionality and opposition from those who consider it a violation of religious beliefs.

With it strong stance against political Islam and religion-based parties, it appears strange that Sisi's administration is not only not promoting this party but also reluctant to register it. Registering this party would have paid dividends outside Egypt as many Western governments would have more inclined to consider President Sisi a liberal and support him. However, the attitude of Sisi administration is non-committal. Why governments against political Islam are not supporting secularism when it also helps them improve their international standing and prospects of aid?

The main reasons appear to be an increasing mixing of Islam with nationalism and a general anger against the Western governments in the Muslim societies. These reasons can also be considered as a form of nativism that rejects the Western influences (but accepts its technological, scientific accomplishments) and searches for authenticity. Secularism, in this discourse and environment, is linked with the West, extreme liberalism and atheism and thus becomes illegitimate on two grounds. First, it is wrong because it is linked with the West which is termed as source of most of the troubles; hence the use of terms collaborators and traitors for secularists. Second, it is castigated because it is against Islam that is considered a 'native' religion and an Arab religion. Both these arguments are obviously false as there is a rich tradition of secularism in Islam and one can be a deeply religious Muslim as well as a secularist.

Muslim/Islamic secularism appears to be an oxymoron but it is not. Nader Hashmi in Islam, the State, and Political Authority: Medieval Issues and Modern Concerns (edited by Asma Afsaruddin) talks about a Muslim secularism which accepts (political, not philosophical) secularism 'while still maintaining a commitment to the principles and rituals of Islam.' This indigenous secularism is authentically Islamic, based on Islamic precepts, but is functionally secular. State is not against religion and religious groups are allowed in the public/political sphere but civil rights of minorities, women and others are rigorously protected.

Abdullahi Ahmed An-Na'im in his book Islam and the Secular State: Negotiating the Future of Shari`a  goes further and claims that secularism and secular state are more consistent with Sharia and history of Muslim societies than Islamic state and Sharia enforcement as a state law (p-268)

Despite criticism, Ouf is hopeful that his party would be registered:
The Constitution bans religious political parties, yet there are religious political parties operating. Why would the (government) committee then ban a secular political party, established in accordance with the Constitution?

Saturday, September 6, 2014

Bangladesh's secular nationalism asserts itself

From 1947 to 1971, Pakistan had two wings, East Pakistan and West Pakistan, separated by Indian peninsula. While West Pakistan (the present Pakistan) was multi-ethnic and multi-linguistic, East Pakistan was ethnically and linguistically homogeneous. Almost all of the people living in East Pakistan were ethnically Bengalis, speaking Bengali language. East Pakistan separated from West Pakistan in 1971 and became Bangladesh after a bloody civil war and an Indian invasion. This separation was based on a rejection of Pakistani religious nationalism and adoption of an ethnolinguistic nationalism, based on the love of Bengali language and Bengali ethnicity. Most Bengalis of the erstwhile East Pakistan felt that Pakistani religious nationalism was a hoax that claimed West Pakistanis and East Pakistanis were not only equal but Muslim brothers/sisters but refused to give Bengalis equal status and their due share in power. Religious parties' near unanimous opposition to Bangladesh's independence movement and the support they provided to Pakistan army during the civil war increased Bangladeshi misgivings to religion's role in politics. Hence, Bangladesh, unlike (pre-1971 or post-1971) Pakistan, chose to be a secular republic. 

The first constitution of Bangladesh proclaimed secularism as one of the four basic principles of the new republic (other three being Bangladeshi nationalism, socialism, and democracy). The new republic also avoided putting a crescent and a star on its flag, revealing the minor role Islam played in Bengali nationalism. Even the green color on the flag is not linked to Islam (as it is in many Muslim-majority nations' flags, like Pakistani, Moroccan, Saudi Arabian flags etc.). Green color symbolizes the lush green land of Bangladesh. Furthermore, Bangladesh's national anthem,  Amar Sonar Bangla (My Golden Bengal). is also a tribute to Bengal and has anti-religion connotations. It was written by Rabindranath Tagore in 1905 against Partition of Bengal on religious lines in 1905. Add to it many speeches/statements of Bangladesh's founder Sheikh Mujib-ur-Rehman and it is beyond doubt that Bangladesh's nationalism was ethnolinguistic and secular.

Despite all the above-mentioned evidence of secular nationalism, Bangladesh quickly reversed its course and dropped secularism. In 1977, fifth constitutional amendment introduced by military ruler Zia-ur-Rehman removed secularism as one of the basic principles and replaced it with the following words "Absolute trust and faith in the Almighty Allah shall be the basis of all actions". In 1988, another military ruler Hussain Muhammad Ershad made Islam the state religion of Bangladesh. For the next fifteen year, religious parties role and overall religious discourse increased and it appeared Bangladesh is still part of Pakistan, with military and religious parties controlling politics and manipulating religious discourse. Awami League, the founding party of Bangladesh, despite its strong attachment to the principle of secularism, also had to accept the reality of the situation as any support for secularism was portrayed as pro-Indian and anti-Islam by its rival, Bangladesh Nationalist Party (BNP).  

While secularism seemed defeated and religious nationalism on the rise, there was one problem; religious nationalism had difficulty legitimizing Bangladesh's separation from Pakistan. It was only on the basis of ethnolinguistic nationalism that a separate country Bangladesh can be explained to the new generation. New generations were thus socialized in a much different environment (more secular) than those ruling elite that grew up in Pakistan.   

Things began to change with the arrival of the twenty-first century. It appears a new generation socialized in the secular nationalism of Bangladesh came of age and started occupying positions of power. Their sentiments were cashed by Awami League, the party of the Sheikh Mujib-ur-Rehman, now led by his daughter, Sheikh Hasina Wajid. Courts, media, and intellectuals also helped and promoted the secularism/restoration of 1972 constitution movement. In 2005, the high court declared fifth constitutional amendment illegal and secularism was reintroduced as one of the basic principles of the republic. Sheikh Hasina then decided to take on religious parties. She established tribunals to punish those who were involved in crimes against Bangladeshis during the war of liberation. It was a politically astute move as it not only mobilized her own voters and many others but also damaged Jamaat-e-Islami (a religious party whose leadership supported Pakistan Army in 1971 and now usually supported her rival BNP). Although, there was an outcry against the partiality of these tribunals, a large majority of Bangladeshis supported these trials and punishments awarded by these tribunals. The trails revived the dubious role played by many religious leaders, implicating political Islam and increasing the support for secularism.

Although, Islam is still the state religion (so 1972 constitution is not fully restored), secularism is definitely on the march and religious nationalism in retreat. A recent evidence of this came when pro-religion rightist BNP also came out against the political role of religion. Tarique Rehman, the current senior vice chairman and the future leader of BNP, said (See Tarique against Religion-based Politics):
We’ve learned from experience that politics of that kind doesn’t work, it didn’t during Pakistan era... There are many among us who have tried to create political essence and outline based on religion. But invariably they have failed.

Friday, June 6, 2014

American Secularism: A historical view of separation of the Church and the State in the US

Introduction
Religions are part of every society’s makeup and even in the most atheistic of societies, one can find more than one religion. The conflict between state and religion, therefore, is always present and states have to come up with a religious policy to deal with this conflict in a consistent way. Given the power religion has over its adherents, it may not be a surprise that most countries regulate religion. Some countries have state religions, while others are hostile toward all religions and can be termed as anti-religious. The US has long been considered an outlier in the developed world in terms of religious attendance. However, not many people know that the US is also an outlier in terms of church-state relationship (Mewes 2002).  

Fox (2008) did a survey of 175 states of the world and concluded that most of the states are not neutral toward religions and are involved in religion regulation. Almost one in four states had official religions and another two-fifths of the countries supported some religions more than others. Around 8% were hostile to all religions and only 3 (less than 2%) supported all religions equally. The US was one of the three states which supported all religions equally. Another measure, more strict than government involvement in religion, was SRAS (Separation of State and Religion). US was only country of the world which neither restricted/regulated the practicing of minority or majority religions, nor passed any religious legislation, proving that the church-state relationship in the US is unique in the world.

The traditional US principle of separation of church and state is based on the First Amendment of the US Constitution and prohibition of the requirements of religious tests for qualification of any office/ trust.

Wall of Separation between Chruch and State
Obama Bulldozes Jefferson’s Wall of Separation
Source: Illinois Family Institute (https://illinoisfamily.org/religious/obama-bulldozes-jeffersons-wall-of-separation/)


There are two religious clauses of the First Amendment. The Establishment Clause states, ‘Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion’. The Free Exercise Clause states, ‘or prohibiting the free exercise thereof’. 

The article 6 of the US Constitution dealt with the requirement of religious tests 
‘… no religious Test shall ever be required as a Qualification to any Office or public Trust under the United States’.

These two clauses and article 6 have been interpreted differently by judges in different eras. Judges have agreed on the minimum application of the Establishment Clause, which is that there would be no established or endorsed church. Beyond this, however, there is no agreement. Similarly, there is controversy about how Free Exercise Clause should be interpreted (Long 2012). 

The US in the Eighteenth Century
To fully understand these injunctions of the US Constitution, one has to study the circumstances in which the Framers of the constitution were operating in late eighteenth century. The following discussion will demonstrate that there was a conflict between an elite, which believed in religious freedom, and masses which did not. In the US Constitution, the elite managed to have their way and religious freedom was guaranteed, without any provisos. However, except for clear restrictions on religious tests in oaths, there was nothing specific about religious freedom in the Constitution which allowed the lower level governments to move towards church-state separation enshrined in the Constitution at their own pace. The necessity for immediate change was further downgraded by the actions of the Supreme Court which did not feel the need to enforce the Bill of Rights. 

Religious diversity
Many of the earliest Europeans who immigrated to the US were religious dissenters. Pilgrims, Puritans, Quakers, Huguenots and many other came to the US after being persecuted in their own countries. Facing persecution in their own countries, unfortunately, didn’t make them accept the importance of religious liberty and many of these groups (e.g. Puritans) tried to persecute others for not following what they believed. 

These efforts, however, gradually lost their force as colonial America became more and more diverse. This diversity in religious practice was not only the result of immigration from different corners of Europe but also changes/divisions in many denominations/sects as grew in the US (Holmes 2006). Another important element in religious diversity of the colonial America was the dominance of different denominations in different colonies. Despite being part of British Empire, major sections of populations in many colonies didn’t follow the Anglican Church. 

Even for someone, who didn’t believe in religious liberty, it was obvious that choosing one religion/sect and making others accept it without fear and fight was impossible (Wright 2010).     

Founding Fathers, Sons of the Enlightenment
European Enlightenment philosophy had enormous influence on the making of the US Constitution. Many of the most important members of the Constitutional Convention and other important personalities of American Revolution were inspired by the Enlightenment thinkers like John Locke, Rousseau, Voltaire, and Montesquieu etc. The ideas of limited government, natural rights, separation of powers and religious liberty were all ideas first popularized by the Enlightenment philosophers. Locke and Montesquieu's writings have been regarded as having the most influence on the US Constitution. Persecution because of one’s religious or other beliefs was an idea close to the Enlightenment thinkers like Voltaire, who himself suffered, and this idea influenced Jefferson, Washington, Madison, and others. 

There is an ongoing controversy on what the Framers truly wanted. Did they want high or low wall of separation? This question assumes that all the Framers thought alike which is implausible. Munoz (2009) has shown though none of the three main founders accepted the strict separation of church and state, Jefferson, Washington, and Madison had each a different view about the relationship between church and state. According to Munoz, ‘There is no single church-state position that can claim the exclusive authority of America’s founding history and that no one Founder’s position can be assumed to reflect the original meanings of the religion clauses’.

Ironically, Thomas Jefferson, who coined the term "wall of separation," allowed the use of federal funds to build churches and to support Christian missionary work.

Religious intolerance
Though circumstances in the colonial America at the time of independence were better than the past and also better than many European countries, it was still a religiously intolerant society. Therefore, it would not be correct to think of religious liberty as a popular concept outside the elite that Founding Father belonged to. Anti-Catholicism was prevalent in newly independent America and there were a large number of laws which restricted the ability of Catholics, Jews, and atheists Americans to live as normal citizens (Davis 2010).    

State Rights
Finally, State Rights was another idea which favored religious liberty, although, at the time of the making of the US Constitution, it didn’t stop states from persecuting or prescribing atheists etc. Due to the diversity of the state’s views on religious liberty and inclination of the Framers to leave most of the powers to the state governments, the original constitution didn’t have much on religious freedom except Article 6 and even after First Amendment was added, it was not enforced for almost a century.  

Church-State Relationship in Practice 
Though the US Constitution didn’t see many changes in terms of its provisions relating to the church-state relationship, the way constitution was applied changed immensely during the two hundred and fifty years of US history. One important thing to be kept in mind is the federal nature of the US government where most of the action happens at the local and state level and the federal government has few tools to affect anything happening at lower levels. Changing church-state relationship at the lower levels was particularly difficult as, on this issue, there was neither agreement in the Congress and nor an appetite to touch this sensitive subject among the legislators. Only Supreme Court had the powers to build the wall of separation that it later did. So, for studying the church-state relationship, rulings of the Court are very important (Jelen 2010).

Looking at the important US Supreme Court decisions relating to religion, one is surprised to see that the first important decision relating to religion was delivered in 1879. Compare it with the 1960s, when seven landmark cases relating to religion were decided by the US Supreme Court. The difference is not because of any constitutional change but because of the changing nature of the American society and the Supreme Court.  

Three periods can be distinguished in the US history in terms of church-state relations.

1776-1868
During this period, the federal government and courts generally maintained separation between church and state in their own sphere of influence. However, federal officers and judges did not apply the separation at the state level.  They considered it a prerogative of the states to decide their relationship with the churches. Therefore, while many states applied the First Amendment whole heartedly, others didn’t and there were no consequences. Maryland raised taxes to support ministers, Massachusetts legislature approved the idea of multiple establishments, and Pennsylvanian officials had to take an oath, declaring their belief in God. Some form of religious establishment continued in many states long after the start of the 19th century (Wright 2010).

It is true that at federal government level, separation of church and state was reiterated in treaty with Tripoli and in the delivery of post on Sundays but federal government influence was minimal in the first half of 19th century and what mattered to people were policies at state and local level where state-religion separation was most often not present. The Supreme Court, the one branch which could have done something about it, was more concerned about state right, rather than individual rights. Justice Marshall opined in Barron v. Baltimore (1933) that the Bill of Rights should not be used for limiting state powers. (Wright 2010)

1869-1939
After the Civil War, 14th Amendment in the US Constitution was passed which among other things made the Bill of Rights applicable to the states of the Union.   

The relevant section of the 14th Amendment of the US Constitution states, ‘..nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law..’

It was only after the passage of 14th Amendment that Supreme Court started applying the Bill of Rights to the states as part of the due process required. This process of ‘incorporation’ of Bill of Rights was, however, a slow process as the Supreme Court was still very sensitive to the local laws. So while Supreme Court gave some decisions applying the Bill of Rights, none of them were related to Establishment Clause or Free Exercise Clause. In fact, the only decision related to religion that Supreme Court gave during this period was related to a federal law. Supreme Court decided in Reynolds v. United States (1879) that Free Exercise Clause allowed universal freedom of belief but not freedom of action which is restricted.   

1940 onwards    
During the 1940s, what has been called ‘the New Deal era’, the Supreme Court broadened its interpretation of the federal government powers. This not only helped the New Deal laws but also had implications for the wall of separation between church and state as both Establishment Clause and the Free Exercise Clause were interpreted more broadly. Justice Hugo Black, an associate Supreme Court judge, was instrumental in bringing this change. The following figure shows the difference between how "wall" was interpreted in the eighteenth century and in the mid-twentieth century.


The two walls of separation
Source: The Gospel Coalition (https://blogs.thegospelcoalition.org/justintaylor/2015/07/16/the-urban-legend-that-thomas-jefferson-believed-in-a-wall-separating-church-and-state/)

The church-state relationship during this era is discussed more broadly in the following section. 

US Government v. Religious Freedom
The need of religious freedom and state often do not conflict. The regular conflict between state and religious freedom is characteristic of only those states which have a state religion and give preference to their state religion over other religions or over atheism or agnosticism. These states usually have laws which make religious conversion difficult (unless it is to the state religion) and put additional liabilities on religious minorities. These states thus restrict an individual’s freedom of belief.

Most of the developed states, like the US, usually do not restrict individual’s freedom of belief and practice. Therefore, state, instead of restricting religious freedom in these countries, protects and promotes religious freedom. The conflicts that arise between religious freedom and such developed states are due to three reasons. First, a state has a responsibility to protect its citizens, especially those who are not in a position to protect themselves. If widely accepted obligation of the state comes into conflict with religious freedom, then religious freedom has to be restricted. Second, a state has to decide when fundamental freedoms of two persons are in conflict. While the fundamentals of the religious freedom are agreed upon, the outer reaches of the religious freedom are hotly contested. Finally, a state may force on its citizen some restrictions, which it considers absolutely necessary for social good. These restrictions are usually very few. 

US experience
Religious freedom in the US was restricted in the 18th and 19th centuries. As discussed above, state restricted the freedom of religious minorities in public sphere. Many states had some form of established religion till late in the 19th century. It was only in the 1830s that Jews were allowed to be elected and vote (Maryland State Archives 2013). Add to it the long history of burning of black churches and restrictions on African-American population of the US, which the Southern states governments, explicitly or implicitly, supported even well into the twentieth century (Brooks 1922, SimmsParis 1998). The issue was, of course, racial hatred but it did make it difficult for African-Americans to participate in their religious practices without fear. So, historically, the US has not done well in terms of protecting the religious freedom of certain sections of its society and despite the apparent legal religious freedom, Christian/Protestant ideas have circumscribed what ‘others’ can do (Sehat 2010). The reason for restriction on religious freedom was, however, not needs of the government but social prejudice.

It is only after the Second World War that major restrictions on religious freedom were based on the need of government. The US government and Supreme Court had to violate one in favor of other in a balancing act. Major areas of disagreement are explained below

Public Schools
A large number of Supreme Court cases relate to public schools where community and individual rights come into conflict on a daily basis. In a large number of cases, Supreme Court has made it clear that any type of religious prayer, instruction and speech goes against religious freedom. Even normal actions, such as giving gifts to one’s class fellows, were denied based on their link with a particular religion.   

Vaccination
The issue of exemption from vaccination based on religious belief is a difficult one. On one side is the religious freedom of a group of people which feel violated and sinned against. On the other side are millions of others which have protected themselves by being vaccinated based on the current medical scholarship but are still vulnerable because of the group which has decided to opt out of this program. In two cases Jacobson v. Massachusetts (1905) and Zucht v. King (1922), Supreme Court decided that the protection of the community is more important than religious freedom of a group (Novak 2005).

Harm to Children
There are many cases in which state restricted the freedom of religion of parents to protect their children from harm. The case of Rebecca Corneau, who was jailed for not revealing the location of her infant baby after one of her previous baby was found starved to death, resulted in a large controversy as it pitted the strange alliance of feminists and religious rights against the state (Wald 2003, Nicilosi 2000).  

Religious Freedom v. other freedoms
A number of cases involving Jehovah Witnesses’ proselytizing practices brought in conflict religious freedom and other freedoms e.g. right of individual privacy or social peace. Although most of these cases were decided on the basis of Free Speech Clause, it brought to a sharp picture the fact that religious practices of some can cause difficulties for many. Another type of cases was related to the workplace. It is hard to unpack Supreme Court decisions and decide whether the court favored religious freedom of an individual or gave preference to ordinary laws/practice. 

Conclusion
The US state has done well in sufficiently accommodating practices of religious minorities. The branch which has most contributed to this atmosphere of religious freedom is the judicial branch. Since the 1940s, Supreme Court and other courts have forced other organs of state to not only stop actions which restrict the rights of a particular religion but also forbidden most religious actions in the public sphere. Critics can point to few decisions which went the opposite way but nobody can deny that the trend is toward more religious freedom. Two recent developments, however, put the future of these gains in doubt. First, 9/11 has started a debate among Americans about whether they have to choose between security and freedom. Many commentators and organizations declare it a false choice but it is difficult to deny that religious practices and freedoms of religious minorities (especially Muslims) are now in sharp focus. The controversy about the building of a mosque near 9/11 site shows emotions can easily be whipped up. Second, the conservative bent of the current Supreme Court (which has been called the most conservative since the 1930s) has shown that if there is a permanent conservative majority in the Supreme Court then many of the liberal gains of the last century could be declared unnecessary or unconstitutional (Chemerinsky 2010). 

Sunday, March 2, 2014

Going to Jail for studying Torah

As discussed in this blog on 11th February 2014 (See 'Is studying religion a service to the state?'), partial exemption of ultra-Orthodox/ Haredi students from military draft has become a major issue in Israel. In national elections last year, parties supporting ending or at least reducing this exemption for Haredi made big gains and the ruling coalition was formed only when PM Netanyahu agreed to change the law. But afraid of the religious community, Bibi was not ready to do much until his hand was forced by a Supreme Court ruling that made the compromise Tal law unconstitutional. 

In March 2014, a new law was proposed by the Israeli government. It was a compromise:

The new legislation sets annual quotas for drafting yeshiva students for military or national service, and mandates criminal penalties against draft evaders. However, the law doesn’t entail complete Haredi conscription, instead calling for a gradual annual increase in the number of ultra-Orthodox 18-year-olds drafted, and still allowing for small numbers of exemptions until 2017. (See Israel passes ultra-Orthodox draft law)

The ultra-Orthodox Jews were not happy. They thought that the law was discriminatory as it targeted only them and not other groups who were also exempted from military service (such as Arab-Israelis who were not required to serve). But mainly they were angry that in a Jewish state, Torah study was not being due importance and they would be sent to jail for studying Torah. They even threatened to quit Israel and emigrate to the US etc. to save their religion.
“If this is the Jewish state, it is one that must have Torah at the center,” said Rabbi Mordechai Bloy, an educator of Haredi youth in Bnei Brak, a mostly Orthodox town near Tel Aviv, as he made his way to Jerusalem. “A Torah scholar must not be treated like a drug dealer.”Protesters’ posters carried slogans like “We will all go to jail” and biblical verses like “Save me, I pray, from the hand of my brother,” a plea made by Jacob, who feared that his brother, Esau, might kill him.

The ultra-Orthodox Jews were on the streets to protest the draft law. Around 300,000 of them protested in Jerusalem.

Defenders of the draft law argued that ultra-Orthodox Jews constitute 10% of the Israeli population and their share is increasing as they favor large families, so continued exemption will lead to a total collapse of the military draft system. Even some right wing parties were supporting the bill. Naftali Bennet of Jewish Home party contended that with 30% first grader coming from Haredi (ultra-Orthodox) homes, Israel could not survive unless ultra-Orthodox share the burden (see Ultra-Orthodox Jews Clog Jerusalem Streets to Protest a Draft Bill). 


Source: Israel passes ultra-Orthodox draft law

The issue as one newspaper pointed out is Israel's religious nationalism.

'In a nutshell, the equal burden law represents the deep schism that divides those who see Israel as the national secular Jewish state and those who see Israel as a place where Jews must live, first and foremost, in obedience to God and His Torah. The first are hinging the wellbeing of Israel on democracy and a strong army. The later hinges it on faith in God.' See Orthodox Jews Threaten to Quit Israel Over IDF Draft

The issue is whether Israel was made for Jews or for Judaism?

In the end, the draft law was passed with 67 voting in favor and only one voting against it in the Knesset. The opposition boycotted the vote.